Mini Reviews

 Courtesy of

Reviews by Stanford’s Operatic Ear:

Photo Aida

*****  5 Stars for Final Act.  A Must for Corelli Fans!

This 1962 Met broadcast offers a solid Amneris and Amonasro in Irene Dalis and Cornell MacNeil, and a lyric and lovely (though, at that time, insufficiently powerful) Aida, Gabriella Tucci. The raison d’etre of the release is Franco Corelli in his best available live performance of this, one of his signature roles. Yes, there are other live Corelli Aida’s available, but they are all from either before or after his prime. Only this set offers the voice at its best. His work in the last act alone, particularly the final scene, merits the 5 star rating and makes the set a MUST for Corelli fans. Corelli’s performance in the first two acts is fine, but better enjoyed on his EMI recording with Nilsson. Here, he has not yet learned to finish the aria in the wonderful fashion heard later and there are other small problems along the way to the fortissimo B flat, but there is compensation ahead. Corelli’s performance in the Nile Scene is not significantly better than the recording until the overwhelming successive A’s which conclude the act. In this scene and elsewhere, though Corelli is as considerate as he can be about overpowering his soprano, the matching of voices is not ideal. Tucci gives us much to enjoy when singing alone, with lovely tone, secure, floating soft notes and musical phrasing. The orchestra and chorus of that era perform as well as could be hoped and Staff Conductor George Schick is at least solidly competent. But finally, this set is essential for those whose thirst for more of Corelli’s voice leads them to pursue performances where he reaches his top form. In the EMI recording with Nilsson, the fourth act scene with Amneris was probably the best part of Corelli’s variable performance, and it is also fine here. Were the final scene the only part of this performance worth listening to (which is not the case), the wonders of that scene alone would make this a must have item for them and a revelation for many others. Faults? Yes. But what a magical soft sound, baritonal lower notes and lush, glowingly powerful top tones, still unequalled, complementing a vivid, involved and passionate characterization. Both singers do beautiful work in the Tomb Scene and anyone wondering up to that point whether this was a worthwhile purchase will have their doubts laid to rest. Corelli’s singing in that scene is addictive; no other word will do. This set has turned up from time to time on Amazon, always for a very high price. After searching for a better buy for about 3 years, I finally found it at a quite reasonable price. The Tomb Scene alone made it well worth the wait. It should be mentioned that the brief Prelude to the final scene is missing here for some reason. Greg Stanford, The Operatic Ear (


Photo De Stepfano

 *****  Hours and Hours of Prime DiStefano


For value for your money, this is unbeatable. Virtually anything worthwhile recorded by Di Stefano during his all too brief prime is represented here, including such rarities as 4 songs from a 1944 Zurich radio broadcast, selections from his La Scala debut in an Italian language Manon and a remarkable 1950 San Francisco operatic concert. The beautiful recordings EMI made of the young tenor in the late ’40’s are here, as well as countless other goodies. EMI, Decca and RCA/BMG can hardly have authorized the selections from their recordings, so this set may not last long. I’d recommend grabbing it while you can. The sound quality is surprisingly good and 10 well filled cd’s for this price is nothing short of incredible (literally). The only drawback is the too-tight cardboard sleeves and the complete absence of notes, but what can you expect when so much music is offered at such a price? No post-1958 Di Stefano is here, so we don’t have to suffer through his self-imposed premature vocal disintegration. What a shame that someone who had such a wonderful voice coupled with that unique and quite audible charm didn’t respect his own gifts enough to take care of them. The smoking, drinking, sexual escapades and all-night poker parties weren’t enough; he also had to sing Corelli/Del Monaco roles and further abuse that divine lyric tenor voice. It’s as if he willed his own destruction, and this man probably never heard of Wotan. But no one was ever blessed with a more beautiful natural gift and this set can’t be too highly recommended. Greg Stanford (The Operatic Ear,


Photo Cav & Corelli

*****  Bernstein and Corelli Make this Cav a Must

This was of course a unique situation, with Bernstein conducting Cav of all things. Those who complained that he was out of his element here had better check the score. By dusting off many traditional cobwebs, he brought this to life as if it were a new work he was trying to promote. Domingo had previously been scheduled for this production, but the labor problems which so delayed the ’69, ’70 season produced various temporary defections, including the young Spaniard’s. Corelli took over, and did he take over! At that time, young Domingo could never have approached Corelli in this one, particularly in this form and cooperating fully with Bernstein. There’s no doubt who’s in charge, but Corelli much more than makes up for his relatively sloppy performance on his commercial set of Cav, where his scooping seriously mars the “Addio”. This time, he delivers the best Turiddu I have ever heard. The Operatic Ear,


Photo Verdi at Met

*****  Verdi at the Met

This is a must have collection. No one has ever touched the likes of Ponselle, Tibbett, Martinelli as Otello, etc., just to name the most obvious of the earlier singers represented here. Price’s incomparable Aida,Bjorling’s only recorded Ballo, Tucker, Bergonzi, Warren….. It would take a book to describe the many wonders of this set. Get it while it lasts. The Operatic Ear,


Photo Samson and Dalila

*****  Samson and Dalila

Read Carefully; Reviews of 2 Perfromances Mixed At Random

 Potential buyers should take a careful look at these reviews. For some reason, they are an indiscriminate mixture of reviews of two different performances. If you order expecting the great Vickers and get Domingo, you’ll have little reason to be glad about it. Sure, Domingo was/is a fine artist, but not in all repertory. Many of his roles were much better suited to either Vickers or Corelli, and in the case of Samson, Vickers was the man.


Mini Photo 9 Turn 1

****  Turandot: Yes, Great, But Not the Best

I’ve read all the reviews here and have owned this ’64 La Scala performance for years. Some of the reviewers seem surprised by the “inferior” sound quality. Clearly, they don’t have much experience listening to off the air live performances of the ’60′s and earlier. No one goes to these priceless performances for sound quality, but for the special joys that live performance before an audience can offer, particularly with such artists as Corelli or conductor Hans Knappertsbusch, high among prominent examples of performers who just couldn’t usually deliver their best under studio conditions. These were theatre creatures, their true stature revealed only there. Also, the cuts objected to by some reviewers were standard practice everywhere then; for sound quality or absolute completeness, such live performances can’t be expected to match studio recordings.That said, I still greatly prefer the ’66 Met performance with the same star duo, with Freni and Mehta (see my review of that one) and the ’61 Stokowski will be preferred by some. Many knowledgeable listeners considered this ’64 version the best up to that time, but 2 years down the road, Nilsson and Corelli, particularly the tenor, surpassed themselves again. As for Sutherland and Pavarotti, despite some fine singing, they were far out of their respective elements when compared with the real thing for this opera, the Valkyrie and the Supertenor.Generally, I yield to no one in my admiration for Bjorling, but Turandot was hardly the best opera to showcase the wonders of Bjorling’s art, despite his beautiful singing in Calaf’s 2 arias (but check out his 1944 recording of “Nessun dorma” for something really amazing). Turandot was never in his repertory and shouldn’t have been.My recommendation: get the studio recording of your choice and also the 3 Nilsson/Corelli live performances mentioned above and choose for yourself. I’m betting that the Met ’66 version will be your favorite too. The Operatic Ear,


 Photo Met Turandot Broadcast

*****  Best Ever Turandot Met Broadcast.

This 1966 Met Turandot surpasses the more famous 1961 Stokowski broadcast, also with Nilsson and Corelli. As is well-known, the singers and chorus in 1961 had a great deal of trouble following Stokowski’s batonless and vague cues. Both the legendary Turandot and Calaf, still unrivalled, offer surer and clearly better performances under Mehta, particularly Corelli, who here gives easily the best of his various available performances of his signature role, his constant artistic progress in the part in the 5 years since the ’61 effort clearly evident here, while the voice, of course, is still in pristine form. Freni is ideal, barring some excessive “crying” after her Act One aria. This is THE Turandot to own. Why, oh why, did the Met choose the 1961 performance over this one for their own official release? Obviously because of Stokowski’s great fame. Incidentally, this 1966 broadcast was the first ever Saturday matinee broadcast from the “new” Met at Lincoln Center, the 1st this writer, then age 19, ever heard, and on rehearing it often beginning 45 years later, I was better able to evaluate its excellence. Once heard, this will inevitably be the Turandot of choice, despite the audio superiority of Nilsson’s 2 studio recordings, the 1st with Bjorling, the 2nd with Corelli. Buy it and find out what you’ve been missing when any other team has subsequently performed it. Incidentally, if you are dubious about the variable Mehta, don’t be. Mehta excels here too, keeping his enormous forces under firm control while allowing the singers room to breathe and phrase. He keeps the whole performance under firm control without strait-jacketing his formidable leading duo. The Operatic Ear,

Photo Parsifal

*****  Greatest Parsifal Ever and at Bargain Rate

This 1951 Wieland Wagner/Hans Knappertsbusch Parsifal, which reopened the postwar Bayreuth Festival, is the greatest Parsifal ever recorded and here costs under $20.00! None of the singers has ever been surpassed on other recordings and Knappertsbusch shows why he reigned supreme as the greatest of all conductors of Wagner’s final masterpiece. The 1951 mono sound is fine, though most will want a second recording in modern sound (I’d recommend the Solti) as an occasional alternative. But this is the performance you will always come back to, as no other recording can ever completely satisfy after hearing this one. Since Knappertsbusch could never adapt to studio recording conditions, one must hear his work in a live performance to understand and appreciate this musical giant’s extraordinary gifts. No libretto is supplied, but most listeners will already have one anyway. RUN now to your computer and snap up this bargain. Then welcome to Wagner’s world, for this is your passport.


Leave a Reply